July 17, 2020
Poor root accommodation results in decline among urban red maples
By the U of A System Division of Agriculture
- Root confinement and poor practices lead to stress and decline of urban trees
- Stressed trees are more susceptible to disease and pests
- Best practices emphasize proper planning and placing the right plant in the right place
FAYETTEVILLE, Ark. — Trees planted along urban streets in cities and towns throughout Arkansas have seen better days. Over the last several years, arborists have noted an increase in the decline, mortality, and removal of urban street trees, which add beauty, shade and other benefits to areas otherwise dominated by vehicle traffic and asphalt.
Colin Massey, agricultural agent for the Washington County Cooperative Extension Service office, said urban tree decline can occur with many species.
“Here in northwest Arkansas, this has been most visible on red maple,” Massey said.
Red maple (Acer rubrum) is widely planted due to its popularity as a street and landscape tree, he said. It was listed as the 2003 Tree of the Year by the Society of Municipal Arborists (SMA).
Red maples offer a fast growth rate but often exhibit shallow root systems and thin bark that is susceptible to sun injury, also known as sunscald. Red maple cultivars such as “Red Sunset” and “October Glory” can provide striking color to the fall landscape, maturing on average to a height of 45 feet, with a canopy spread of 35 feet.
“Urbanization places significant stress on forests, which provide numerous benefits to the surrounding ecosystem,” Massey said. “Ecosystem services are environmental, economic and health benefits obtained from nature. With forests and trees, we receive many benefits such as water uptake and filtration, erosion control, nutrient cycling, oxygen production, temperature regulation, aesthetics and wildlife habit.”
These benefits also offset many costs that residents would otherwise be required to mitigate or even pay for, such as increased energy bills or water treatment due to soil erosion, Massey said. Research also shows that landscape trees significantly increase home values.
The underlying causes of urban tree decline: roots
Oftentimes, trees planted in urban areas, especially those lining streets or in medians that separate directional traffic, are simply not afforded the space their roots will need to grow as the tree matures. Sixteen square feet may seem like a vast expanse for a yearling; for a 15-year-old maple or oak, not so much.
“Tree roots are hidden from view, which may lead one to understate their importance,” Massey said. “Roots not only supply trees with vital nutrients and water, but also provide food storage and anchor the tree structurally.
“A concept that is not well understood is that tree roots mostly grow outward, laterally, extending at least to the drip-line of the leaf canopy, and often two or three times that distance, depending on the species and maturity,” he said. The drip-line is an imaginary line defined by the spread of the leaf canopy at which rain would fall unobstructed by leaves.
Most tree roots, especially fine-absorbing roots, grow in the top 12 inches of soil where oxygen, water and nutrients are most available. Roots are sensitive to abiotic disorders — environmental factors such as drought, excessive moisture, chemical exposure, physical disturbance from construction, soil compaction or lack of a suitable root zone. These factors stress trees, making them even more susceptible to secondary injury from pathogens, insects or exposure, Massey said. Root injury can be difficult to diagnose, as symptoms often occur years after planting.
Often too late to save
Extension agents, specialists and arborists frequently receive calls from worried residents and municipal officials on how to save their dying trees, Massey said. Common symptoms of decline include reduced leaf size, early fall color change, crown thinning, and branch dieback.
“Sadly, the point at which the decline is recognized is often too late to remedy,” he said. “Trees may experience rapid death or may decline across several years.”
Circumstances in these urban environments often result in secondary problems, including increased disease, poor root growth, sunscald and insect infestation such as scale insects or trunk borers.
Across Arkansas, red maples have been — and continue to be — planted in urban landscapes and as street trees. All too often, however, these beautiful trees are planted in areas far insufficient to support their required root zone, for example, a 4-by-6-foot patch of grass between a street curb and a sidewalk.
Compounding this issue are the use of impervious surfaces such as sidewalks, streets and driveways that limit root expansion, as well as compacted soil from construction. There is also often stress from environmental factors such as pollution, excess nutrients or repeat applications of herbicides over the root zone. If trees are initially stressed by root confinement, they are more susceptible to injury from these secondary pathways.
Another common problem that can accelerate decline is improper mulching, Massey said.
“Mulch is often piled nearly a foot high, touching the trunk or root flare,” he said. “This method of mulching not only traps moisture against the trunk, which may accelerate decay and introduce disease or trunk failure, but also limits oxygen and water exchange to roots. Mulch should never exceed 3-4 inches of depth, and an inch or two of space should be left between the mulch and trunk.”
Proper planning to achieve long-term tree health
The best time to save an urban tree from these dismal fates is, of course, before it’s even planted.
“Thoughtful consideration should be given during the planning and implementation phase to select the correct plants for a specific location,” Massey said. “Consider mature size, the tree’s root zone and what adequate maintenance will look like.
“While there are many factors — and often, multiple factors — that can lead to tree decline, following best practices on the front end can significantly extend the lifespan of urban trees,” he said.
To receive the ecosystem services and benefits of trees, arboriculture experts agree that the number of surviving trees, as well as planting rates, have to exceed the death and removal rate, especially in rapidly urbanizing areas, Massey said.
“If considerable forethought is not given to planning, maintenance, and sustaining urban tree health, rapid and widespread decline of urban plantings is likely to continue,” he said. “Municipal planners, urban foresters, developers, and homeowners should consider best practices during the planning phase of development with emphasis on ‘right plant, right place.’”
About the Division of Agriculture
The University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture’s mission is to strengthen agriculture, communities, and families by connecting trusted research to the adoption of best practices. Through the Agricultural Experiment Station and the Cooperative Extension Service, the Division of Agriculture conducts research and extension work within the nation’s historic land grant education system.
The Division of Agriculture is one of 20 entities within the University of Arkansas System. It has offices in all 75 counties in Arkansas and faculty on five system campuses.
The University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture offers all its Extension and Research programs to all eligible persons without regard to race, color, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, national origin, religion, age, disability, marital or veteran status, genetic information, or any other legally protected status, and is an Affirmative Action/Equal Opportunity Employer.
# # #
University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture
Cooperative Extension Service