
Interim Report
Recommended Management Practices
Baitfish Research Verification Committee
Arkansas Fish Diagnostic Laboratories
The University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service and Agricultural
Experiment Station have been conducting research verification trials for major
row crops since the 1980's, and for catfish culture since 1993. Research
verification programs are a public demonstration of the implementation of
research-based Extension recommendations in a commercial-scale farming
environment. Program cooperators agree to manage a section of their farm
according to Extension recommendations. Cooperating producers keep records on
production inputs and outputs. Extension personnel monitor various production
parameters and make management recommendations to the producer on a regular
basis. Finally, the data are analyzed to verify the utility of the Extension
recommendations for optimizing the enterprise's profitability.
The essence of aquaculture research verification is to provide intensive
monitoring of commercial ponds in which recommended research-based management
protocols are being implemented. The intensive monitoring results in a
comprehensive database of water quality, input use, stocking, and harvesting
data from commercial ponds that greatly exceeds the data available from normal
farm production records. The comprehensive quality of the data provide for more
accurate estimates of survival, yield, and feed conversion ratios than data
obtained from interviews in which data are based on normal farm records. The
principal benefit of aquaculture research verification is to determine if the
total set of research-based extension recommendations applied on a commercial
farm produces yields, feed conversions and costs consistent with results from
research trials.
The Baitfish Research Verification Program (BRVP) is a new program initiated in
2003 in Arkansas. Arkansas is the leading baitfish producing state and the
University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff is the leading research institution for
baitfish production and economics. A new interdisciplinary verification
committee consisting of researchers and extension specialists was formed to
develop a revised set of recommended management practices for commercial
baitfish culture based on current research and practical experience. These
management practices formed the basis of the specific management protocol for
the BRVP trials started in May 2004. Three species make up the majority of
farm-raised baitfish in Arkansas (golden shiners Notemigonus crysoleucas,
fathead minnows Pimephales promelas, and goldfish Carassius auratus). However,
the present BRVP focus on golden shiner production only.
There are several culture practices for golden shiners. The most extensive
method, requiring the least skill and management, is the wild or free spawning
method. In the wild spawning method, golden shiners are allowed to spawn
naturally on vegetation around the edges of the pond and fry are raised together
in the same pond with adults. This method is simple, but reproduction and yields
are variable and diseases are easily passed from adults to the young.
A more intensive method is the egg or mat transfer method. Egg transfer requires
more skill and much more labor, equipment and facilities than wild spawning but
producers obtain higher and more reliable yields. In this method, mats are used
as spawning material and are placed in brood ponds. Mats with eggs are collected
from the brood ponds and moved to fry rearing ponds or to a hatchery.
There are two basic methods of fry rearing: with or without juvenile transfer.
Stocking rates of eggs or fry in ponds will vary according to the method used.
Fry rearing ponds are stocked at low density when fish are to be grown directly
to market size within the same pond without transfer. In the transfer method,
some ponds are initially stocked at high density to produce juvenile fish
("peewees"). Throughout the season, a fraction of the fish population
is transferred to other ponds at lower densities to be grown to market size. The
advantage of the juvenile transfer method is that a known number of fish are
stocked. This allows for better inventory control and allows producers to
manipulate stocking densities and feeding rates to produce desired sizes of fish
at the desired time of the year to meet market demand.
The most intensive method of producing golden shiners today includes
transferring eggs to hatchery followed by juvenile transfer. However, survival
rates and yields still vary tremendously from pond to pond. Nonetheless, good
management practices may increase survival and yields in golden shiner ponds.
Stocking densities and feeding rates in growout ponds, the last phase in the
production cycle, vary according to the market niche of each farmer. Each market
niche requires a particular size fish at a particular time of the year. To avoid
these market specific practices, the BRVP will focus only on the juvenile
production stage. The BRVP in 2004 will focus on providing good management
practices to produce a reliable source of juvenile "peewee" golden
shiners by reducing mortality and increasing yields.
Three cooperating producers distributed among three Arkansas Counties were
selected for the program for a total of five verification ponds. Two
verification ponds are located on a cooperator farm in Prairie County. Two other
verification ponds are located on a cooperator farm in Greene County. The fifth
verification pond is located on a cooperator farm in Lonoke County. The
cooperating golden shiner farmers were equipped with hatchery facilities (Figure
5) and were using the method of egg transfer to a hatchery and juvenile
transfer for growout. Cooperating producers agreed to manage the verification
ponds according to the recommended management practices for about one summer
season or until the last harvest of juveniles from the pond. The program
coordinator verify all stocking and harvesting procedures and visits each farm
weekly to measure afternoon temperature and pH and make recommendations for
action the following week. Alkalinity and hardness will be measured at the
beginning and at the end of the verification trial and as necessary for pond
treatments. If unexpected situations arise, it is the responsibility of the
cooperator to contact the program coordinator for guidance. The program
coordinator collects production and water quality data each week and maintains
regular contact with the producer. At the end of the verification program,
survival, feed conversion ratio, and yield will be calculated. Feed, aeration
and other production expense data will be collected and utilized to estimate
operating costs, net returns, and breakeven prices.
The Baitfish Research Verification Program (BRVP) represents a public
demonstration of the implementation of research-based Extension recommendations
in a commercial-scale farming environment. The program focuses on intensive
golden shiner production enterprises that use the method of egg transfer to a
hatchery followed by juvenile transfer for growout. The objectives of the
program are as follows:
1. Develop a specific recommended management protocol for juvenile golden shiner production.
2. Develop a comprehensive database of key production
parameters (feed conversion ratio, yield, and survival) of commercial juvenile
golden shiner ponds which will provide a basis for quantifying risks involved in
baitfish farming.
3. Identify the most important types of "normal" losses in golden
shiner production with estimates of the magnitude of these losses.
4. Verify the utility of research-based Extension recommendations on improving
yield and survival of commercial juvenile golden shiner production ponds.
5. Identify areas of golden shiner production that require further research.
6. Improve and refine existing Extension recommendations.
7. Improve and refine the specific management protocol for future verification
trials.
8. Utilize and incorporate data and findings from the BRVP into Extension's
educational program at the county and state level.
9. Increase the participating county Extension agents' expertise in baitfish
production.
10. Increase cooperating baitfish farmers' understanding of the research-based
Extension recommendations.
11. Increase the number of ponds that cooperating baitfish farmers manage
according to Extension recommendations the year following the end of the
program.
RECOMMENDED MANAGEMENT PRACTICES -
JUVENILE PRODUCTION
The following recommendations target a reliable and consistent production of
juvenile golden shiner around a size of 1.1 lb/1,000 fish and a total yield over
500 lb/ac.
Ponds with old plankton blooms may have high populations of predaceous copepods
(Frimpong and Lochmann 2001) that can eat fry (Valderrama et al. 2000).
Therefore, production should begin with an empty pond and remaining puddles
should be treated with hydrated lime. The filling process should start only 4 to
7 days prior to the expected stocking date. Groundwater is recommended because
it is usually free of predators, suspended solids, pollutants, fish diseases,
and trash fish. A week after stocking, green water from an adjacent pond may be
pumped into the fry pond to accelerate the establishment of a plankton bloom and
reduce pumping costs. However, it is important to wait about a week before
adding green water because water with old plankton blooms may have high
populations of predaceous copepods that can eat fry. The need for fertilization
varies with pond history and fertility. When needed, ponds may be fertilized
with a mixture of organic and inorganic fertilizers to encourage the growth of
natural foods. A bloom density of 10-15 inches, Secchi disk visibility, should
be targeted. Based on the abundance of predators and pond history, the
application of Baytex may be recommended in consultation with your aquaculture
Extension specialist.
Once the pond is filled, a 3/6 water management system may be used to minimize
pumping costs (Pote et al. 1988). Ponds should be filled to 3 inches below the
top of the overflow pipe. This allows for 3 inches of rainwater storage. If the
water level falls to 6 inches below the overflow level, the pond should be
pumped up to the 3 inch level.
Total alkalinity and hardness should be above 20 ppm but the desired range is
from 75 to 200 ppm as CaCO3.
Ponds should be equipped with electric paddle-wheel aerators at 0.5 hp/ac or
greater. It may not be necessary to turn aerators on during the first 3 weeks
after stocking. However, morning (7:00-9:00 AM) dissolved oxygen concentrations
should be monitored closely during that 3-week period and aeration initiated
when the dissolved oxygen concentration is expected to drop below 4 ppm. After
that initial 3-week period, the aerator should be turned on by midnight every
night in the summer and turned off at 8:00 AM.
Stocking is best done in early morning when water is cool and pH is not too
high. Exposing young fry to high pH may result in lower survival. The pH of the
pond to be stocked should be checked the afternoon before and should be below 9.
At the time of stocking, pH should be below 8.5. If pH is above recommended
values, stocking should be postponed for few days until pH reading are in the
recommended range. If stocking has to be delayed by more than ten days due to
high pH, the application of Baytex may be recommended in consultation with your
aquaculture Extension specialist. When stocking is recommended, fry should be
transferred to the ponds in plastic bags filled with oxygen. The number of fry
per bag should be estimated by the volumetric method. The stocking rate should
be within the range of 500,000-1,000,000 fry/ac. Inadequate acclimation
(tempering) for temperature differences between bag water and pond water may
stress or kill fry. The bags should be floated in the pond until the water in
the bag is within a few degrees of the pond temperature. Ideally, bags should be
tempered in vats filled with pond water before leaving the hatchery.
From the stocking date, fish should be fed twice per day. Fish should be fed
meal (36% protein) for the first few weeks and later switched to crumbles (32%
protein). The feeding rate should start at 5 lb/ac/day divided into two feedings
per day. During the first two weeks, fry stay along the pond edges. Therefore,
the feed should be applied at the pond edge. Fry abundance along the pond edge
can be checked with a "pie tin on a stick". Thirty minutes after each
feeding, fish behavior should be observed. If fish are still schooling at the
surface, more feed should be applied. Feeding rates should reach 15 to 25
lb/ac/day by the end of the culture period.
When sick or dead fish are observed, when feeding activity drops rapidly, and
before transfer and harvests, farmers should transport six or more fish to the
diagnostic laboratory and follow the recommendations of the fish health
specialist. In Arkansas, fish diagnostic services for fish farms and private
ponds are provided by the Fish Disease Diagnostics Laboratories of the
University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff. The best way to ship live samples of sick
fish to the diagnostic lab is to put fish in a bucket or cooler of pond water
and drive them directly to the lab. The best fish sample is sick fish that show
obvious signs of disease or are alive but resting in the pond edge. Pond owners
should walk around the pond and search for sick fish. Random fish can be
collected by seining, or cast nets but these samples will only be useful in
cases where a very high percentage of fish in a pond have an active form of the
disease. Fish that are caught while fish feed are not useful because sick fish
tend to stop feeding. Along with sick fish, a water sample from the affected
pond should always be submitted to the diagnostic lab. This sample should
consist of at least 250 ml (about 8 ounces) of water. It is important to rinse
the jar several times in pond water before collecting the sample. Traces of
soda, juice, detergents, or other chemicals contaminating sample bottles may
lead to inaccurate water test results. The container should be kept cool and out
of direct sunlight. For additional information on how to collect and ship a fish
sample, contact the Fish Disease Diagnostics Laboratory in your area.
Farmers should maintain adequate records of the most important production
parameters for each pond, such as:
· Hours of aeration
· Stocking records
· Harvest records
· Daily feeding (amount, type, and diet composition)
· Mortality estimates
· Dissolved oxygen concentration
· Water quality parameters
· Medications or treatments
· Water pumping information
· Quantity and price of chemicals and fertilizer used
Additionally, records of all operating expenses, fixed expenses, and revenue
should be maintained and analyzed once a year to assess the financial status of
the enterprise.
Farm workers should be given proper instructions on farm safety at least once a
year. Check with your local county Extension office or Fish Disease Diagnostics
Laboratory of your area on the availability of the "Fish Farming Safety
Video", which is available in English and Spanish.
The farm is located in Prairie County.
The pond has a water surface area of 2.4 acres and is equipped with 0.75-hp
Aer-o-latorâ electric floating vertical pump aerator and 0.5-hp airlift pump (Table
1).
On 10 May 2004 the well water was turned on to start filling the pond. On that
afternoon, the temperature of the water was 23ºC and the pH was 7.3. The
following morning (May 11th), an estimated total of 2,484,000 fry were stocked
in the pond (Figure 4),
which represented a stocking density of 1,035,000 fry/ac. At the time of
stocking, the pH was 7.5, which was safe for the fry, and the temperature was
21ºC.
Fry were transferred from the hatchery to the pond in plastic bags of
approximately three gallons of water and filled with oxygen. The bags were
floated in the pond until the water in the bag was within two degrees Fahrenheit
of the pond temperature (Figure
3). The number of fry in each bag was estimated using a volumetric method. A
0.4-lb (181 ml) water sample was taken from each bag. The sample was poured
through a sieve to capture the fry (Figure
1). Thereafter, captured fry were poured into a graduated cylinder (Figure
2). The number of fry per bag was estimated using the following formula:
F = B * C * M ÷ S
Where: F = number of fry in the bag
B = total
weight (lb) of the water and fry in the bag
C = 1,200
fry/ml (Appendix 1)
M = number of
ml of fry in the graduated cylinder
S = sample
weight of 0.4 lb
Water quality parameters were measured post stocking (Table 2) followed by weekly monitoring of pH and water temperature (Table 3).
The pond has a water surface area of 4.5 acres and is equipped with 0.75-hp
Aer-o-latorâ electric floating vertical pump aerator and 0.5-hp airlift pump (Table
1).
On 10 May 2004 the well water was turned on to start filling the pond. The two
following mornings (May 11th and 12th), an estimated total of 4,271,580 fry were
stocked in the pond (Figure
4), which represented a stocking density of 949,240 fry/ac.
Fry were transferred from the hatchery to the pond in plastic bags of
approximately three gallons of water and filled with oxygen. The bags were
floated in the pond until the water in the bag was within two degrees Fahrenheit
of the pond temperature (Figure
3). The number of fry in each bag was estimated using a volumetric method. A
0.4-lb (181 ml) water sample was taken from each bag. The sample was poured
through a sieve to capture the fry (Figure
1). Thereafter, captured fry were poured into a graduated cylinder (Figure
2). The number of fry per bag was estimated using the following formula:
F = B * C * M ÷ S
Where: F = number of fry in the bag
B = total
weight (lb) of the water and fry in the bag
C = 1,200
fry/ml (Appendix 1)
M = number of
ml of fry in the graduated cylinder
S = sample
weight of 0.4 lb
Water quality parameters were measured post stocking (Table 2) followed by weekly monitoring of pH and water temperature (Table 3).
The first harvest of this pond occurred on 16 June 2004. A total of 1,744,375 juvenile golden shiners (697.75 lbs) were removed from the pond with 3 seine hauls. There were 2,500 head/lb with a mean length of 29 + 3 mm (Graph 1) with a mean weight of 0.182 g + 0.055 g (Graph 2).
This farm is located in Greene County.
The pond has a water surface area of 10 acres with no permanent aeration. On 12
May 2004 the well water was turned on to start filling the pond (Table
1). The following
morning (May 13th), the temperature of the water was 19.9ºC and DO was 9.5
mg/L. On the same day (May 13th), an estimated total of 30,745,200 fry were
stocked in the pond (Figure
4), which represented a stocking density of 3,074,520 fry/ac. A large number
of dead fry were observed in the first few bags that were most likely caused by
low DO in the plastic bags. At the time of stocking, the pH was not measured.
However, since the pond was recently filled and the weather was overcast and
rainy, pH was assumed to be within the tolerable limits of golden shiner fry.
Fry were transferred from the hatchery to the pond in plastic bags of
approximately three gallons of water and filled with oxygen. The bags were
floated in the pond until the water in the bag was within two degrees Fahrenheit
of the pond temperature (Figure
3). The number of fry in each bag was estimated using a volumetric method. A
0.25-lb (113 ml) water sample was taken from each bag. The sample was poured
through a sieve to capture the fry (Figure
1). Thereafter, captured fry were poured into a graduated cylinder (Figure
2). The number of fry per bag was estimated using the following formula:
F = B * C * M ÷ S
Where: F = number of fry in the bag
B = total
weight (lb) of the water and fry in the bag
C = 1,200
fry/ml (Appendix 1)
M = number of
ml of fry in the graduated cylinder
S = sample
weight of 0.25 lb
Water quality parameters were measured post stocking (Table 2) followed by weekly monitoring of pH and water temperature (Table 3).
The pond has a water surface area of 10 acres and is equipped with a 10-hp
paddlewheel aerator (Table 1). On 13 May 2004 the well water was turned on to start
filling the pond. The following morning (May 14th), the temperature of the water
was 20ºC with a pH between 7.5-8.0. On the same day (May 14h), an estimated
total of 18,858,480 fry were stocked in the pond (Figure
4), which represented a stocking density of 1,885,848 fry/ac.
Fry were transferred from the hatchery to the pond in plastic bags of
approximately three gallons of water and filled with oxygen. The bags were
floated in the pond until the water in the bag was within two degrees Fahrenheit
of the pond temperature (Figure
3). The number of fry in each bag was estimated using a volumetric method. A
0.25-lb (113 ml) water sample was taken from each bag. The sample was poured
through a sieve to capture the fry (Figure
1). Thereafter, captured fry were poured into a graduated cylinder (Figure
2). The number of fry per bag was estimated using the following formula:
F = B * C * M ÷ S
Where: F = number of fry in the bag
B = total
weight (lb) of the water and fry in the bag
C = 1,200
fry/ml (Appendix 1)
M = number of
ml of fry in the graduated cylinder
S = sample
weight of 0.25 lb
Water quality parameters were measured post stocking (Table 2) followed by weekly monitoring of pH and water temperature (Table 3).
This farm is located in Lonoke County.
The pond has a water surface area of 12 acres and is equipped with a 10-hp paddlewheel aerator (Table 1). On XX May 2004 the well water was turned on to start filling the pond. The following morning (May XXth), the temperature of the water was 26ºC. On the same day (May XXth), an estimated total of 12,358,293 fry were stocked in the pond, which represented a stocking density of 1,029,858 fry/ac.
Fry were transferred from the hatchery to the pond in hauling tanks. Three
hatching tanks were emptied into a tub that holds approximately 100 lbs of water
(Figure 6). A 6 ml sample was taken from this tub and was individually counted
(Figure 7). Fry were then bucketed into the hauling tanks
(Figure 8). Hauling
tanks were tempered with pond water until the water temperatures were equal (Figure
9). Fry
were then drained into the pond. The number of fry stocked was estimated using
the following formula:
F = ((H*P)/6)*W
Where: F = number of fry
H = number of
fry/6 ml sample
P = 453.6
(number of grams/pound)
W = total
weight from tanks sampled
Water quality parameters were measured post stocking (Table 2) followed by weekly monitoring of pH and water temperature (Table 3).
The pond has a water surface area of 15.8 acres and is equipped with a 10-hp paddlewheel aerator (Table 1). On XX May 2004 the well water was turned on to start filling the pond. On 5 June 2004, there were 5,676,650 fry stocked into the pond, which had a temperature of 27°C. Additionally, on 12 June 2004, there were 6,142,240 more fry stocked into the pond that had a temperature of 28°C and pH of 7.5. An estimated total of 11,818,890 fry were stocked in the pond, which represented a stocking density of 748,031 fry/ac.
Fry were transferred from the hatchery to the pond in hauling tanks. Three hatching tanks were emptied into a tub that holds approximately 100 lbs of water (Figure 6). A 6 ml sample was taken from this tub and was individually counted (Figure 7). Fry were then bucketed into the hauling tanks (Figure 8). Hauling tanks were tempered with pond water until the water temperatures were equal (Figure 9). Fry were then drained into the pond. The number of fry stocked was estimated using the following formula:
F = ((H*P)/6)*W
Where: F = number of fry
H = number of
fry/6 ml sample
P = 453.6
(number of grams/pound)
W = total
weight from tanks sampled
Water quality parameters were measured post stocking (Table 2) followed by weekly monitoring of pH and water temperature (Table 3).
One of the objectives of the BRVP is to identify areas of golden shiner
production that require further research to improve Extension recommendations.
Areas of production that require further research that have been identified
during the development of the present management protocol include the following:
1. Egg disinfection
2. The best juvenile golden shiner size to transfer
3. Relation between stocking density of juveniles and size at harvest.
4. Egg freezing
BAITFISH RESEARCH
VERIFICATION COMMITTEE
Nathan Stone - (Temp) Program Coordinator
Office: (870) 575-8138
Mobile Phone:
Dr. Andrew Goodwin, Fish Health Specialist
Office: (870) 575-8137
agoodwin@uaex.edu
Dr. Carole Engle, Economist
Office: (870) 575-8523
cengle@uaex.edu
Dr. Hugh Thomforde, Extension Aquaculture Specialist
Office: (501) 676-3124
hthomforde@uaex.edu
Dr. Nathan Stone, Extension Fisheries Specialist
Office: (870) 575-8138
nstone@uaex.edu
Dr. Rebecca Lochmann, Fish Nutrition Specialist
Office: (870) 575-8124
rlochmann@uaex.edu
ARKANSAS FISH DIAGNOSTIC LABORATORIES
Lonoke Fish Diagnostic Laboratory
Lonoke Agricultural Center
2001 Highway 70 East
Lonoke, AR 72086
Telephone 501-676-3124
FAX 501-676-7847
Newport Fish Disease Diagnostic Laboratory
ASU-Newport
7648 Victory Blvd
Newport, AR 72112
Office: 870-512-7837
Fax: 870-512-7838
Mobile 870-540-7805
Pine Bluff Fish Diagnostics Laboratory
(Entrance to the rear of 1890 Building at the corner of Spruce and Oliver
Street)
Telephone 870-575-8137 (office)
870-575-8034 (lab)
870-575-8123 (secretary)
870-543-8162 (FAX)
Pine Bluff - Commercial shipping address
Fish Diagnostic Laboratory
UAPB Warehouse
1200 N. University Dr.
Pine Bluff, AR 71601
Pine Bluff - US Mail
Fish Diagnostic Laboratory
University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff
P.O. 4912
1200 N. University Dr.
Pine Bluff, AR 71601
Engle, C.R., N. Stone, and E. Park. 2000. An analysis of production and
financial performance of baitfish production. Journal of Applied Aquaculture
10(3):1-15.
Frimpong, E. and S.E. Lochmann. 2001. An evaluation of treatments affecting
zooplankton populations for water re-use and effluent reduction. Aquaculture
2001, Book of Abstracts: 238.
Pote, J.W., C.L. Wax, and C.S. Tucker. 1988. Water in catfish production:
sources, uses, and conservation. Mississippi Agricultural and Forestry
Experiment Station, Special Bulletin 88-3, November 1988.
Valderrama, D, S.E. Lochmann, and M. Jackson. 2000. Predation of Cyclopoid
Copepods on Sunshine Bass Fry. North American Journal of Aquaculture 62:
144-148.
Stocking characteristics of golden shiner ponds used for 2004 baitfish research verification program.
|
Ponds |
|||||||
| Parameter | Units | A1 | A2 | B1 | B2 | C1 | C2 |
| Location | county | Prairie | Prairie | Greene | Greene | Lonoke | Lonoke |
| Area | acres | 2.4 | 4.5 | 10 | 10 | 12 | 15.8 |
| Date stocked | 5/11/04 | 5/12/04 | 5/13/04 | 5/14/04 | 5/29/04 | 6/12/04 | |
| Aeration | hp/ac | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.0 | 1.0 | 0.8 | 0.6 |
| Stocking density | fry/ac | 1,035,000 | 949,240 | 3,074,520 | 1,885,848 | 1,029,858 | 748,031 |
Initial water quality parameters measured in the golden shiner ponds for the 2004 baitfish research verification program.
|
Ponds |
||||||
| A1 | A2 | B1 | B2 | C1 | C2 | |
| Date | 6/4/04 | 6/4/04 | 6/9/04 | 6/9/04 | 6/11/04 | 6/11/04 |
| Time | 14:30 | 14:30 | 13:00 | 13:00 | 13:45 | 13:45 |
| Temperature (ºC) | 31 | 31 | 29 | 29 | 31 | 21 |
| pH | 10.0 | 10.0 | 9.0 | 9.0 | 9.5 | 10 |
| TAN (mg/L) | 0.4 | 0.2 | 0.5 | 0.3 | 0.4 | 0.5 |
| NH3(mg/L) | 0.4 | 0.2 | 0.3 | 0.2 | 0.4 | 0.5 |
| Nitrite (mg/L) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Chloride (mg/L) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 74 | 83 |
| Alkalinity (mg/L) | 180 | 240 | 40 | 200 | 240 | 240 |
| Hardness (mg/L) | 136.8 | 188 | 51.3 | 222 | 239 | 222 |
Weekly pH/temperature reading in the golden shiner ponds for the 2004 baitfish research verification project.
| Ponds | ||||||
| Week of: | A1 | A2 | B1 | B2 | C1 | C2 |
| 6/7/04 | 10/30º | 10/30º | 9/29º | 9/29º | 9.5/31º | 10/31º |
| 6/14/04 | 9.5/28º | 8/27º | 9/30º | 9/31º | 10/35º | 7.5/31º |
| 6/21/04 | 10/29º | 9.5/28º | 9.5/28º | 8.5/28º | ||
Temperature is in ºC.


A volumetric estimate is a common way of estimating the number of fry that are stocked out into a pond. This technique involves taking a sample of fry with a sieve that holds a known weight of water. These fry are then poured into a graduated cylinder. Then the number of fry is estimated by multiplying the total weight of water and fry in the bag by the number of ml of fry in the graduated cylinder, then multiplying that number by 1,200 (Dr. Nathan Stone, University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff). This value is then divided by the sample weight. The 1,200 value is an estimate of the number of fry per ml. In order for this technique to be accurate, the 1,200 value has to be the true average of fry/ml.
The 1,200 fry/ml was verified during the stocking out of golden shiner fry
during one of the verification trials. Three samples were collected from the
graduated cylinder during the volumetric estimation process from four ponds that
were brought back to the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff to be counted with
a fry counter. Fry were preserved in a 50% alcohol and 50% water solution until
counting could be performed.
Results are illustrated below in Appendix table 1. Two sample were discarded
during the fry counting method due to excessive error in the counting process.
The mean number of fry per ml as determined by the fry counter was 1,218 + 85.
These results indicate that a value of 1,200 fry/ml is an accurate estimate,
even on a commercial scale.
Appendix table 1. Verification of volumetric estimate with fry counter.
|
Sample |
Sample size (ml) |
Volumetric estimate of fry |
Fry counter number of fry |
Fry/ml as determined by fry counter |
| 1 | 5.2 | 6,240 | 5,468 | 1,052 |
| 2 | 5.6 | 6,720 | 6,653 | 1,188 |
| 3 | 6.0 | 7,200 | 7,575 | 1,263 |
| 4 | 7.0 | 8,400 | 8,459 | 1,208 |
| 5 | 7.2 | 8,640 | 8,463 | 1,175 |
| 6 | 7.8 | 9,360 | 9,933 | 1,273 |
| 7 | 8.0 | 9,600 | 10,824 | 1,353 |
| 8 | 9.0 | 10,800 | 10,830 | 1,203 |
| 9 | 9.0 | 10,800 | 11,742 | 1,305 |
| 10 | 11.0 | 13,200 | 12,714 | 1,156 |
Updated 11/09/09